Wednesday, December 5, 2012

Critique: "Departure"

This story is about a woman mentally preparing herself to move to Boston for a new job. During her preparation, she has an anxiety attack and loses conception of time and (I think) hallucinates a vision of her mother telling her to wait to leave until the morning. It was unclear to me what exactly happened during the final page and a half of the story. Elements of magical realism seemed evident, but I am not sure what parts of the story actually happened and what parts didn’t.

This is a very fascinating and engaging draft driven by hard action. The story moves very quickly and really doesn’t let up until the final few paragraphs. I liked some of the details (the philosophy book and its contents, the six-hundred-thread-count sheets, the and the repeated acknowledgment of the time) wonder if they could be stronger or more pronounced in order to push the reader toward a more definitive conclusion of the story. It isn’t exactly clear to me what the significance of the time and how living in the moment corresponds with Danielle’s situation.

As a final note, what is the emotion that slips inside of her as she sets down the philosophy book? This is a key point in the story that is somewhat overlooked or at least understated. As a reader, I’m looking for a little more clarity on what this emotion is and why it’s so important, other than the fact that it causes the rest of the story to go where it does.

No comments:

Post a Comment